Create Wellness class action alleges gummies contain less creatine than advertised

By Top Class Actions | July 1, 2026

Category: False Advertising

Man, hands or dumbbells in gym workout, training or exercise for strong muscle growth, healthcare wellness or bodybuilding. Zoom, texture or heavy metal weights for fitness coach or personal trainer — (Photo Credit: PeopleImages/Shutterstock)

Create Wellness class action lawsuit overview:

Who: Plaintiff John Connolly filed a class action lawsuit against Create Wellness Inc.
Why: Connolly alleges the company’s creatine gummies do not contain the amount of creatine promised on the label.
Where: The Create Wellness class action lawsuit was filed in New York federal court.

A new Create Wellness class action lawsuit alleges the company falsely advertises its creatine gummies as containing more creatine than they actually do.

Plaintiff John Connolly filed the class action complaint against Create Wellness on April 22 in New York federal court, alleging violations of state and federal consumer laws.

According to the class action lawsuit, Create Wellness falsely advertises its creatine gummies as containing 4.5 grams per serving of creatine, when, in fact, they contain significantly less.

Connolly claims he purchased Create Wellness’ creatine gummies multiple times through a subscription service, believing they contained the advertised 4.5 grams of creatine per serving.

However, testing of the product he received showed it contained about 10% less creatine than advertised, the lawsuit alleges.

Create Wellness creatine gummies degrade over time, lawsuit says

Connolly alleges independent laboratory testing of the creatine gummies he bought showed they contained only about 4.1 grams of creatine per serving, or approximately 10% less than what is claimed on the label.

Furthermore, a third-party organization, Food Now, previously tested Create Wellness’ 1.5-gram creatine gummies in 2024 and found that they contained only about 80% of the advertised creatine content, the class action lawsuit says.

Connolly alleges the underfilling of Create Wellness’ products is due to a formulation flaw: the creatine interacts with the water inside the gummies, causing the creatine content to deteriorate over time.

He claims the amount of creatine in Create Wellness’ products is critical to consumers who are seeking to supplement their creatine intake.

Connolly wants to represent anyone in the United States who purchased Create Wellness’ creatine gummies from any point of sale, except its website, during the applicable statute of limitations period.

The lawsuit brings claims under New York’s General Business Law, breach of express warranty and unjust enrichment.

Connolly seeks certification of the Create Wellness class action, damages, fees, costs and a jury trial.

Olly supplement brand is also facing a class action lawsuit after tests allegedly revealed its Metabolism Gummy Rings contained minimal levels of apple cider acetic acid.

What do you think of the claims made in this Create Wellness class action lawsuit? Let us know in the comments.

The plaintiff is represented by Philip L. Fraietta, Matthew A. Girardi and Caroline C. Donovan of Bursor & Fisher P.A.

The Create Wellness class action lawsuit is Connolly v. Create Wellness Inc., Case No. 7:26-cv-03324, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.