Top Class Actions’s website and social media posts use affiliate links. If you make a purchase using such links, we may receive a commission, but it will not result in any additional charges to you. Please review our Affiliate Link Disclosure for more information.
A class action lawsuit has been filed against McGraw-Hill, Pearson Education, and other book retailers alleging that the companies conspired with each other to increase prices of their textbooks and eliminate any competitors in the marketplace.
The lawsuit was filed by college book resellers who claim that the book publishers and retailers created a product that forced students to buy new books (instead of used materials sold by the plaintiffs) by every college student in every semester.
The plaintiffs claim that the product, called “Inclusive Access,” limits access to higher education course materials and is exclusive to the defendants. This thus limits competition in the marketplace, the plaintiffs state.
Under the “Inclusive Access” plan, students who are enrolled at every college and university allegedly have no choice but to purchase their books in one format (the Inclusive Access plan), from one source (the defendant retailers), imposed by one group (the defendant publishers).
The plaintiffs claim that, historically, the higher education market for course materials included a “full and open” competition between retailers at universities. However, the defendants’ monopoly has allegedly changed this.
According to the class action, McGraw-Hill and other publishers control between 80 and 90 percent of the market nationwide in the producing and selling of college course materials.
In addition, the plaintiffs claim that McGraw-Hill and other retailers generally pay universities for the right to operate an on-campus store and they operate in more than 50 percent of the nationwide on-campus stores.
“As the sale of Course Materials (over the Internet, by Amazon, and through rentals) increased competition and finally began lowering the price and increasing the availability of Course Materials, the Publishers looked for ways to reduce or eliminate competition and increase their revenues,” the McGraw-Hill class action lawsuit states.
The plaintiffs claim that, through antitrust actions, the defendant publishers do not compete with each other to publish course materials for each university’s classes.
“This case challenges the Defendants’ conspiracy and their improper acquisition and use of monopoly power to irreparably harm the higher education course materials market by eliminating competition and thereby eliminating any consumer choice,” the McGraw-Hill class action lawsuit states.
The plaintiffs allege that the defendants are hiding their anticompetitive behavior in the form of technological advancements. The defendants’ end goal is to eliminate their competition and raise prices, according to the class action lawsuit.
The college books class action alleges that the defendants’ actions will result in a “total monopoly” of the market for the sale of books at every college and university, which would eliminate any competition for the sale of course materials.
According to the plaintiffs, McGraw-Hill’s and the other defendants’ actions will harm the entire higher education market because the scheme would result in a complete lack of choice for students to buy their books used as well as having students pay a higher price for their college materials.
“It further has stifled innovation in the marketplace and eliminated and otherwise harmed through improper means the Defendants’ competitors and any secondary product markets, including those of the Plaintiff Retailers and other Independent Collegiate Retailers,” the McGraw-Hill class action lawsuit alleges.
Are you a college student and pay a high price for course materials? If so, leave a message in the comments section below.
The plaintiffs are represented by John C. Phillips Jr. and David A. Bilson of Phillips Goldman McLaughlin & Hall PA, Nicole Williams and Mackenzie S. Wallace of Thompson & Knight LLP and Stuart Cochran and L. Kirstine Rogers of Steckler Gresham Cochran PLLC.
The McGraw-Hill College Books Class Action Lawsuit is Campus Book Company Inc., et al. v. McGraw-Hill Global Education Holdings LLC, et al., Case No. 1:20-cv-00102, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2024 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.
404 thoughts onMcGraw-Hill Class Action Says Book Publishers Fixed Textbook Prices
I am a college student who works for the college bookstore. Big publishers target big departments at colleges so that they will use their books, which can only be sold new for upwards of $300 because they contain access codes.
Add me
We are Putting our daughter through college and the price of books is ridiculous and IF they can even return them, they are offered $10 for a $150-$200 book. Also, they will only take back 20-30 books, when they sold hundreds. Just so wrong when these kids and parents we are already struggling to help make our kids lives better.
Yep, just paid $139.00 for an “all inclusive” ONLINE, NOT HARD COVER, Physics book that we could not purchase anywhere else. The cost of the book was added to our tuition bill. Was told there was no other option, but through the publisher. West Chester University Bookstore Rep/buyer said that she had never seen such a high price for an all inclusive book before, and since our son must have it to take the course for his major, we were SOL and had to buy it. When I asked if we could buy a hard copy, or if this book was on Amazon, I was told the publisher only had online access, and the publisher was the only access for the book. Crazy.. All inclusive is a scam, and the prices are outrageous. Would be happy to be a member of this case. I never paid fees for books like this when I was in college. And there is nothing we can do about it.
Please add me I have 2 daughters impacted
add me
I have put 2 kids through college and the money that we paid for books is totally unacceptable!! Please add me
Please add me. Not in school, graduated 13 yrs ago. Still have the overpriced books. I refused to sell them for a few bucks.
Current Student. Please add me
Yes book up to 200.00
I am a PhD student and have been in school for my undergrad and graduate education for many years and through MANY books. Please add me