Keurig Coffee Pod Settlement Unfair for Some Consumers, AGs Argue
(Photo Credit: gioiak2/DepositPhotos.com)

The distribution of a $31 million settlement — reached in a deal with Keurig Inc. amid allegations it forced a monopoly in the single-serve coffee pod market — is under dispute.

An order granting a motion to intervene was granted to Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul and Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody last Tuesday in a New York federal court, Law360 reported.

In the motion, the attorneys general said they hadn’t been able to resolve a dispute with the Class counsel on how the settlement would be distributed across the states, and were concerned some states’ residents would get much less than others.

Late last year, Keurig agreed to pay $31 million to resolve claims it violated antitrust laws by fixing the price of its Keurig K-Cup products, and the settlement has been given preliminary approval.


It benefits those who purchased Keurig K-Cup Portion Packs from retailers other than Keurig between Sept. 7, 2010, and Aug. 14, 2020, in all states other than Mississippi and Rhode Island; between March 24, 2011, and Aug. 14, 2020, in Mississippi; or between July 15, 2013, and Aug. 14, 2020, in Rhode Island.

According to the plaintiffs in eight consolidated class action lawsuits, Keurig violated antitrust laws in order to monopolize the market for single-serve coffee pods. This monopoly allegedly allowed the company to artificially fix the price of Keurig K-Cup products — subjecting consumers to financial strain that wouldn’t exist in a healthy market.

However in the latest motion, Illinois and Florida representatives say that under the current settlement distribution plan, “purchasers in Illinois and Florida will be harmed by recovering less than other arguably similarly situated consumers,” Law 360 reported.

They argue that the settlement plan pays different amounts to people in different states due to the states’ differing consumer laws. 

In some states, indirect purchasers of products or services impacted by antitrust violations can’t seek damages in federal court due to not having repealed the U.S. Supreme Court’s Illinois v. Illinois Brick ruling. 


Consumers in the states where damages can be sought are getting up to a full refund, while residents of the other states will get only eight percent each of what they spent, Law360 reported.

The intervention bid is not being opposed by Keurig or the buyers who reached the deal. 

However, the buyers said in a response that the plan was fair to consumers in Illinois and Florida. They pointed out that Illinois does not allow class actions to be brought under its antitrust law, and that Florida’s statute does not allow indirect buyers to recover treble damages for antitrust breaches. For more details on the settlement and how to file for compensation, click here. 

Meanwhile, Keurig is facing a number of other class action lawsuits. In September, an environmentally conscious coffee drinker from New England launched a class action lawsuit over claims that Keurig coffee pods are not recyclable, though they are labeled otherwise.

What do you think of the motion to intervene in the settlement? Let us know in the comments! 


Illinois is represented by Kathryn Hunt Muse, Blake L. Harrop and Richard S. Schultz of the Office of the Illinois Attorney General. Florida is represented by Patrick Crotty and Lizabeth A. Brady of the Florida Office of the Attorney General.

The indirect buyers are represented by Robert N. Kaplan, Gregory K. Arenson, Hae Sung Nam and Jason A. Uris of Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer LLP, Mark C. Rifkin, Thomas H. Burt and Patrick Donovan of Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz LLP, and Clifford H. Pearson, Daniel L. Warshaw and Matthew A. Pearson of Pearson Simon & Warshaw LLP.

The Keurig Monopoly Class Action Motion to Intervene is In Re: Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serve Coffee Antitrust Litigation, Case No. 1:14- md-02542, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

We tell you about cash you can claim EVERY WEEK! Sign up for our free newsletter.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Please note: Top Class Actions is not a settlement administrator or law firm. Top Class Actions is a legal news source that reports on class action lawsuits, class action settlements, drug injury lawsuits and product liability lawsuits. Top Class Actions does not process claims and we cannot advise you on the status of any class action settlement claim. You must contact the settlement administrator or your attorney for any updates regarding your claim status, claim form or questions about when payments are expected to be mailed out.

68 Comments

  • Nadine Rody July 19, 2021

    Please add me as I bought alot of the coffee pods in the past.

  • Michelle Johnson July 18, 2021

    Add me to the list I buy cases of keurig pods.

  • Mary Lou Erickson July 1, 2021

    Please add me.

  • Felicia Wade June 30, 2021

    I have been buying this product since two and eight and and I still buy it add me to the list

  • JOHN DEGENNARO June 16, 2021

    add me please

  • Joseph kawucha June 11, 2021

    Please add me I have bought very many keurig pods

  • Carrie June 9, 2021

    Do people really actually get added to class actions just by submitting a comment on this website saying “Please add me”? I doubt it!

  • Gail Coalley June 1, 2021

    add me

  • Rosa Soto June 1, 2021

    please add me

  • Arneather Gaines May 27, 2021

    Add me ArneatherGaines 302 Barney Upper Rd Thomasville Al 36784

  • Lisa Jeffery May 21, 2021

    I have receipts for my purchases of hundreds of pods.

    • karole coleman June 3, 2021

      Please add me I have bought them for years

  • Natalie May 20, 2021

    Bough very many

  • Debbie Green May 20, 2021

    add me

  • dora justman May 20, 2021

    please add me

  • Daniel Serrano May 18, 2021

    Please add me

  • Darrell B Stewart May 18, 2021

    Pls Add Me

    • Mary coleman May 20, 2021

      Add me too

  • Karen Sheehan May 18, 2021

    Please add my name

  • Angela jackson May 14, 2021

    Add me please

  • Mark May 13, 2021

    Pls add me

  • Anita brewer May 12, 2021

    Add me

  • Reginald Gaines May 12, 2021

    Add me

  • Arneittia Brewer May 12, 2021

    Add me

  • Arneather Gaines May 12, 2021

    Add me

  • Shirley J Smith May 11, 2021

    I have purchase several Keurig and pods thru the years. Please make sure to add me. Thanks.

  • Sharon Lloyd May 11, 2021

    Please add me

  • Michelle Crary May 11, 2021

    Please add me

  • Missy Baker May 2, 2021

    Please add me

  • Jimmy Roberson April 30, 2021

    I use this machine and k-cups. I’d like to be added to the case.

  • Judy Lee April 30, 2021

    I have a Kerug coffee maker k-cup machine. Please add me to the claim.

  • Judy Lee April 30, 2021

    I would like to be added to the claim.

  • Jane April 29, 2021

    Add meJane

  • Dawn April 29, 2021

    Add me

  • Syrece A Williams April 29, 2021

    Add me

  • Judith Tower April 29, 2021

    Please add me I have bought those since I got my kerig

  • MS LINDA Powell April 29, 2021

    OMG PLEASE AD ME ALSO I BUY THESE EVERYTIME I GO TO THE STORE THANK YOU

  • David Verdoorn April 29, 2021

    Add me

  • Bryan Holley April 29, 2021

    Please add me.

  • Patricia G Holley April 29, 2021

    Please add me.

  • Joe April 29, 2021

    Add me please

  • Albert April 29, 2021

    Add me please

  • Renae April 29, 2021

    Please add me

  • Agnes April 29, 2021

    Add me please

  • Penni Cruikshanks April 28, 2021

    Please add me

  • Denise Lee April 28, 2021

    Add me to the claim

  • WALTER W WEED April 28, 2021

    Add me

  • Dan April 28, 2021

    Add me

  • cathy thompson April 28, 2021

    Add me

  • Michele Barker April 28, 2021

    Add me to the claim

  • Pamela Vandergriff April 28, 2021

    Add me

  • Debra K Sapp April 28, 2021

    Add Me

  • Zakiyah A Moore April 28, 2021

    Please add me

  • Nancee Samloff April 28, 2021

    Please add me

  • Jane April 27, 2021

    Add me

  • Marsha Rogers April 27, 2021

    Curious as to how this works.

  • PATRICIA BISHOP April 27, 2021

    PLEASE AD ME

  • Angela jackson April 27, 2021

    Please add me

  • LISA HAWKINS April 27, 2021

    Please add me

  • Lori Gartland April 27, 2021

    The photo you have attached to this article is not accurate. You have not attached a Keurig coffee pod but a Nespresso coffee pod.

  • debra April 27, 2021

    Add me

  • Heather Leyva April 27, 2021

    Add me

  • jennifer bowen April 27, 2021

    please add me

  • tommie tipton April 27, 2021

    add me

  • thomas jones April 27, 2021

    add me

  • linda l cooper April 27, 2021

    add me

  • Marcella April 27, 2021

    Add me

  • Vicki April 27, 2021

    Please add me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts