Top Class Actions’s website and social media posts use affiliate links. If you make a purchase using such links, we may receive a commission, but it will not result in any additional charges to you. Please review our Affiliate Link Disclosure for more information.
A federal judge recently certified a Class of drivers in a class action lawsuit alleging that California toll operators use personal information to collect toll payments. The judge also trimmed some of the claims in the case.
U.S. District Court Judge Andrew J. Guilford certified one of the proposed Classes in the California toll class action.
Judge Guilford certified the privacy Class, made up of California drivers whose information was allegedly shared with third parties in order to collect toll payments.
In the original definition of the privacy Class included any individual who “had their privacy rights violated by the improper dissemination of their [personal identifying information] in connection with the toll roads operated by defendants.”
However, before certification, it had to be ensured that the Class was not a “fail-safe” Class. The court imposed limits on the Class’ membership so that qualifying Class Members were those drivers who had their information shared with specific agencies and debt collection offices in violation of the California Streets and Highways Code Section 31490.
Although the privacy Class was certified, the second penalty Class was not. Judge Guilford found that the proposed Class failed to satisfy Rule 23 requirements which consider providing notice to Class Members.
“In short, the proposed class is too muddled for the court to understand what a representative action would look like, or what purpose it would serve,” Judge Guilford stated.
Despite the fact that only one proposed Class was certified by the court, class counsel voiced their approval of the move in a statement.
“We are pleased with the court’s certification of the privacy class in this hardfought matter — this decision is an important step forward for drivers on the toll roads in Orange County seeking compensation for the improper dissemination of their personally identifiable information to third parties,” said Class counsel in a statement to Law360.
In a separate order, Judge Guilford kept due process claims but denied excessive fines claims, finding that the Transportation Corridor Agency (TCA) California toll fines were not excessive as the plaintiffs had claimed.
“Regarding penalties, the initial TCA penalty for a toll violation is $57.50, and the maximum combined TCA penalty for any toll violation is $100,” Judge Guilford said in his ruling. “A penalty of either $57.50 or $100 isn’t a grossly disproportional punishment for the failure to pay a $32.32 toll. The TCA penalty scheme may therefore be applied in a constitutional manner.”
The California toll class action was originally filed in February 2016. In April of the same year, the Transportation Corridor Agency (TCA) motioned to dismiss the claims, citing multiple holes in the plaintiffs’ argument.
In January 2017, Judge Guilford found that the plaintiffs in the case did not exhaust all administrative remedies before filing their California toll class action, but gave them the chanc to amend their claims and resubmit as a consolidated class action.
Plaintiffs are represented by Michael J. Flannery and Matthew Prewitt of Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca LLP; Blake J. Lindemann of Lindemann Law Firm APC; and Helen I. Zeldes, Andrew J. Kubik, and Ben Travis of Coast Law Group LLP.
The California Toll Road Class Action Lawsuit is In re: Toll Roads Litigation, Case No. 8:16-cv- 00262, in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2024 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.
16 thoughts onCalifornia Toll Roads Class Action Lawsuit Granted Certification
Please count me in this lawsuit!!!!
The claimed biolation was for $4 dollars and they are charging me $100 penalty without having made one attempt to reach me about my violation until they could collect $100 in penalty. This tollroad fee and violation method is unethical
Please Count Me In… The toll roads is placing a license hold on all my vehicles which are in good standing. Due to an alleged $50,000 outstanding fee for a vehicle that is not owned by me but on my account. The Vehicle that owes 50k has been totaled in a car accident. However the hold are being placed on vehicles that have never violated. These guys are extortionists!
Please Count Me In… The toll roads is placing a license hold on all my vehicles which are in good standing. Due to an alleged $50,000 outstanding fee for a vehicle that is not owned by me but on my account. The Vehicle that owes 50k has been totaled in a car accident. However the hold are being placed on vehicles that have never violated. These guys are extortionists!
They are saying my mom owe $45,000!!!! My mom never drove the toll but let her neighbor use the vehicle and never received a letter about tolls in the mail.
I have case pending against me right now from Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson LLP they are threatening to send my collection the CA State Franchise Tax Board for collection! Contact me!
I want to join too I’ve paid my over $3000 already for violations I had in 2017. I’m driving on expired registration now bc they are asking me for $2000 more now which I refuse to pay! My overall tolls were only $300!!!!
Can I joint class action lawsuit. I’m getting violations tickets since 2015 and my vehicle never use Toll Road OC. DMV block my registration twice (wrongly not my vehicle) And I cant stop it.
Where can I find a good attorney to help with my current toll road situation. I have called the toll road many times to get copies of what they are charging me for and they can’t and wont send me an invoice or prove of the fees.
Can I join the class action?