Allstate Can’t Dismiss Robocall Class Action Lawsuit
By Jessica Tyner
A California federal judge has refused to dismiss a proposed class action lawsuit accusing Allstate Insurance Co. of violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. The TCPA is designed to protect consumers from receiving unwanted automated calls and text messages. The insurance giant, also known for protecting people, is accused of contacting people on their mobile phones without their consent.
On June 10, 2013, U.S. District Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton agreed to trim several claims from the Allstate TCPA class action lawsuit, but rejected Allstate’s request to drop the case.
One of the claims Hamilton dismissed was the allegation that Allstate knowingly and willfully violated the TCPA, simply because the two defendants didn’t oppose Allstate’s request to dismiss this claim. The plaintiffs did, however, oppose the dismissal of the claim that Allstate negligently violated the TCPA — and it stuck. Allstate tried to get around this by saying since the company made settlement offers (and one was accepted), the entire case should be thrown out. Judge Hamilton didn’t agree.
The Plaintiffs’ Allegations
Allstate alleged used an automated dialing system to contact the two plaintiffs, which is in blatant violation of TCPA regulations. Additionally, these two people had never been Allstate customers, had never asked to be contacted, and had no interest in being contacted. It’s unclear how Allstate got their numbers, but it’s possible that the company was randomly automating calls within certain regions.
In other TCPA lawsuits that aren’t class action lawsuits, the acceptance of a settlement may render a lawsuit dismissed. However, class action lawsuits are a different beast. Since one TCPA victim didn’t accept an offer, that means the violation of the TCPA rule(s) have not been fully addressed. Although Allstate tried every tactic to get the class action lawsuit dismissed, in the end those attempts were in vain.
Call Intentions
In the case of the Allstate robocall lawsuit, it turns out that whether or not a person is the intended recipient of a call doesn’t matter. Judge Hamilton has stated that whether or not Allstate meant to call a certain plaintiff is a moot point — a factual point, but in the end the victim is still the victim.
One of the reasons TCPA laws came into play is because people who receive sales calls on their cell phone may be paying to receive them. This is often the case with mobile phones, since consumers who don’t have unlimited minutes may be paying out of pocket to receive telemarketing outreach they never signed up for.
Most people have received a call for someone else, but may not realize that could be a TCPA violation. If the call is from a business, organization, company or agency and if an automated dialing system was used in any way, that likely breaks TCPA rules. However, many consumers aren’t aware of TCPA rules or that they’re a victim who deserves compensation.
The Allstate Robocall Class Action Lawsuit Case is Richard Chen, et al. v. Allstate Insurance Co., Case No. 13-cv-00685 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.
The plaintiffs are represented by Abbas Kazerounian and Matthew M. Loker of Kazerouni Law Group APC, Joshua B. Swigart of Hyde & Swigart and Todd M. Friedman of Law Offices of Todd M. Friedman.
Did You Get Unwanted Calls from a Company?
It’s not just sales calls that violate TCPA law. If you’ve received an automated call or text from a company which you didn’t sign up for in writing, you might have a TCPA legal claim.
Find out more about TCPA rules at the Text Message Spam, Cell Phone Call TCPA Class Action Lawsuit Settlement Investigation right now. You’ll be able to submit your information for a free case review. An attorney will contact you if you have a case to further discuss your TCPA claim review with no obligation or cost.
Updated June 29th, 2013
All class action and lawsuit news updates are listed in the Lawsuit News section of Top Class Actions

