Monsanto recently motioned to toss an earlier $25 million jury verdict in a Roundup cancer lawsuit, arguing that the trial shouldn’t have ever taken place.
According to Monsanto and parent company Bayer’s lawyers, the trial was invalid because U.S. District Judge Vincent Chhabria allowed unreliable expert witnesses to present their findings to the jury. Due to these inadmissible opinions, Monsanto says that “the trial in this case never should have been held” and asks the Ninth Circuit panel to reverse the verdict.
Judge Chhabria allowed the opinions to move forward in July 2018, finding that the opinions on glyphosate and cancer contended by the expert witnesses were “shaky but admissible.” As a result of Judge Chhabria’s ruling, the case could move forward to the first federal bellwether trial surrounding Roundup cancer.
In 2019, the six-person jury at this trial awarded a California man $75 million in punitive damages and $5 million in compensatory damages for his 2015 non- Hodgkin’s lymphoma diagnosis. Judge Chhabria later reduced punitive damages to $20 million.
Now, Roundup lawyers seek a reversal of this trial and subsequent verdict. Specifically, the company lawyers take issue with the opinion heard from pathologist Dr. Dennis Wiesenberger.
Dr. Wiesenberger’s testimony failed to pass the U.S. Supreme Court’s gatekeeping standard for expert testimonies. Despite this, Judge Chhabria allowed his testimony to be considered by jurors. The court reportedly applied a more lenient standard for expert testimonies than those seen by other circuit courts.
“At a minimum, this court needs to state quite clearly that it hasn’t diverged from all the other circuits in the [U.S. Supreme Court case]standard that is applied,” Monsanto’s lawyers said. “The gatekeeping function is a real one and that courts cannot allow irrelevant or unreliable testimony to go to the jury on a theory that, well, cross examination can handle this.”
U.S. Circuit Judge Ryan Nelson noted that Monsanto’s lawyers have “a pretty tight minefield” to work within if they want the Roundup verdict to be reversed. Judge Nelson pointed to several other reversals in the Ninth Circuit in which courts improperly excluded expert testimonies, the reverse of the current situation.
“It strikes me that we’ve got a lot of cases where district courts exclude and then get reversed,” Judge Nelson said. “I’m sympathetic to the district court here who said ‘I’ve learned my lesson.’ We like district courts who learn the lesson. He seems to have done the right thing here.”
Monsanto Says Testimony Shouldn’t Have Been Heard by the Jury
However, Monsanto and Bayer lawyers say that Wiesenberger’s testimony was “so unreliable” that it should have never been heard by the jury.
For example, during the trial, Wiesenberger opposed this view by concluding that the California man’s non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma was not idiopathic – or without a known cause – due to the level of exposure to glyphosate he experienced over his 25 year career working with Roundup. However, company lawyers say that over 70% of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma cases are idiopathic.
This is not the first Roundup verdict that Monsanto and Bayer have contested. Not all of Monsanto’s attempts have been victories. Some of these attempts have been successful, while others have failed.
In July 2019, Monsanto successfully appealed a $2 billion jury verdict which was awarded to a California couple who both developed non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma after being exposed to Roundup. Initially, the jury awarded the couple $55 million in compensatory damages and $2 billion in punitive damages.
Although Monsanto couldn’t completely wipe out the verdict, the court did agree that such high damages were excessive and unconstitutional. As a result, the plaintiffs award was reduced to $17 million in compensatory damages and $69 in punitive damages.
In July 2020, a California appeals court refused to overturn a $289.2 million jury verdict awarded in August 2018 to a school groundskeeper. Shortly after being handed down by the jury, this award was reduced to $78.5 million – though Monsanto asked later for the award to be entirely dismissed. Like in the 2019 case, this award was not overturned but was reduced by 74% to include $20.5 million in damages.
These awards were not part of an ongoing settlement which is being negotiated between Bayer and consumer lawyers. Earlier this year, a settlement seemed as if it were on the horizon, but troubles continue to mount for Bayer. In fact, the company has threatened to file bankruptcy in the face of mounting Roundup verdicts and legal liability.
Join a Roundup Weed Killer Cancer Class Action Lawsuit Investigation
If you or a loved one developed non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, B-cell lymphoma, T-cell lymphoma, chronic lymphocytic leukemia or hairy cell leukemia after using Roundup as a farm worker or home gardener, you may have a legal claim. Legal migrant farmworkers may also seek help.
Learn more by filling out the form on this page for a case evaluation with an experienced Roundup lawsuit attorney.
Please note: Top Class Actions is not a settlement
administrator or law firm. Top Class Actions is a legal news source
that reports on class action lawsuits, class action settlements,
drug injury lawsuits and product liability lawsuits. Top Class
Actions does not process claims and we cannot advise you on the
status of any class action settlement claim. You must contact the
settlement administrator or your attorney for any updates regarding
your claim status, claim form or questions about when payments are
expected to be mailed out.
We use cookies to improve functionality and performance, enhance user experience, and provide tailored content. Click Accept if you consent. Click Change Settings if you want to tailor the use of your cookies.
Accept
Read more
Change Settings
Cookie Box Settings
Cookie Box Settings
Privacy settings
Decide which cookies you want to allow.
You can change these settings at any time. However, this can result in some functions no longer being available. For information on deleting the cookies, please consult your browser’s help function.
Learn more about the cookies we use.
With the slider, you can enable or disable different types of cookies:
This website will:
Remember which cookies group you accepted
Essential: Remember your cookie permission setting
Essential: Allow session cookies
Essential: Gather information you input into a contact forms, newsletter and other forms across all pages
Essential: Keep track of what you input in a shopping cart
Essential: Authenticate that you are logged into your user account
Essential: Remember language version you selected
This website won't:
Remember your login details
Functionality: Remember social media settings
Functionality: Remember selected region and country
Analytics: Keep track of your visited pages and interaction taken
Analytics: Keep track about your location and region based on your IP number
Analytics: Keep track of the time spent on each page
Analytics: Increase the data quality of the statistics functions
Advertising: Tailor information and advertising to your interests based on e.g. the content you have visited before
Advertising: Gather personally identifiable information such as name and location
This website will:
Remember which cookies group you accepted
Essential: Remember your cookie permission setting
Essential: Allow session cookies
Essential: Gather information you input into a contact forms, newsletter and other forms across all pages
Essential: Keep track of what you input in a shopping cart
Essential: Authenticate that you are logged into your user account
Essential: Remember language version you selected
Functionality: Remember social media settings
Functionality: Remember selected region and country
This website won't:
Remember your login details
Analytics: Keep track of your visited pages and interaction taken
Analytics: Keep track about your location and region based on your IP number
Analytics: Keep track of the time spent on each page
Analytics: Increase the data quality of the statistics functions
Advertising: Tailor information and advertising to your interests based on e.g. the content you have visited before
Advertising: Gather personally identifiable information such as name and location
This website will:
Remember which cookies group you accepted
Essential: Remember your cookie permission setting
Essential: Allow session cookies
Essential: Gather information you input into a contact forms, newsletter and other forms across all pages
Essential: Keep track of what you input in a shopping cart
Essential: Authenticate that you are logged into your user account
Essential: Remember language version you selected
Functionality: Remember social media settings
Functionality: Remember selected region and country
Analytics: Keep track of your visited pages and interaction taken
Analytics: Keep track about your location and region based on your IP number
Analytics: Keep track of the time spent on each page
Analytics: Increase the data quality of the statistics functions
This website won't:
Remember your login details
Advertising: Use information for tailored advertising with third parties
Advertising: Allow you to connect to social sites
Advertising: Identify device you are using
Advertising: Gather personally identifiable information such as name and location
This website will:
Remember which cookies group you accepted
Essential: Remember your cookie permission setting
Essential: Allow session cookies
Essential: Gather information you input into a contact forms, newsletter and other forms across all pages
Essential: Keep track of what you input in a shopping cart
Essential: Authenticate that you are logged into your user account
Essential: Remember language version you selected
Functionality: Remember social media settings
Functionality: Remember selected region and country
Analytics: Keep track of your visited pages and interaction taken
Analytics: Keep track about your location and region based on your IP number
Analytics: Keep track of the time spent on each page
Analytics: Increase the data quality of the statistics functions
Advertising: Use information for tailored advertising with third parties
Advertising: Allow you to connect to social sites
Advertising: Identify device you are using
Advertising: Gather personally identifiable information such as name and location