An Illinois man says thousands of L.L. Bean customers have been left in the lurch now that the outdoor retailer has suddenly changed its return policy.
Plaintiff Victor Bondi says the company has violated federal and state consumer protection laws by changing its century-old unlimited return policy.
He seeks to have the old policy enforced for all L.L. Bean customers who made a purchase before the company issued the change in terms.
Bondi, a self-described faithful L.L. Bean customer for many years, argues that purchasers like himself have a right to expect L.L. Bean to honor the warranty under which their purchases were made.
He claims that by unilaterally changing the warranty terms, L.L. Bean is in violation of the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act.
Since 1912, L.L. Bean has offered a completely unlimited return policy on all its products. Customers could return L.L. Bean goods at any time and for any reason. Bondi quotes the retailer’s namesake founder as saying that he didn’t consider a sale complete until the product was worn out and the purchaser was still satisfied.
The company finally changed that return policy last week. L.L. Bean announced on Friday that it will now accept returns only within one year of the date of purchase.
Bondi says the former, no-end-date return policy was a core reason why he and other customers made purchases from L.L. Bean. For more than 100 years, customers have relied on the company’s completely unlimited warranty in choosing to purchase L.L. Bean goods, he says. By revoking that warranty, he argues, the company is denying these customers the benefit of the bargain.
Bondi’s L.L. Bean class action lawsuit shows pictures of two L.L. Bean catalog covers from as recently as Spring 2015, showing phrases like “100% Satisfaction Guarantee. No Conditions. No End Date” and “At L.L. Bean, your satisfaction doesn’t have a time limit.”
He quotes from L.L. Bean’s website, which until recently allegedly said, “Our products are guaranteed to give 100% satisfaction in every way. Return anything purchased from us at any time if it proves otherwise.”
The company has built its valuable brand on that warranty, according to the L.L. Bean class action lawsuit. Bondi quotes an NPR article from September 2013 in which L.L. Bean’s Chief Marketing Officer cited the warranty as “great marketing for the company.”
The executive said he had never heard the value of the warranty questioned in any meeting – he had only been asked whether the company promotes the warranty enough.
Bondi is proposing to bring his claims on behalf of all persons who purchased goods from L.L. Bean before Feb. 9, 2018.
He is asking the court to enforce L.L. Bean’s original, unlimited return policy as previously warranted. He also seeks awards of damages, restitution and disgorgement, and court costs and attorneys’ fees, all with pre- and post-judgment interest.
Bondi’s attorneys are Ben Barnow, Erich P. Schork, Jeffrey Blake and Anthony Parkhill of Barnow and Associates PC.
The L.L. Bean Return Policy Class Action Lawsuit is Bondi v. L.L. Bean Inc., Case No. 1:18-cv-01101, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.
UPDATE: On June 28, 2018, an Illinois federal judge dismissed a class action lawsuit accusing L.L. Bean Inc. of wrongly changing its lifetime product warranty to a one-year return policy after finding the plaintiff did not have standing to bring the case.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2024 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.
96 thoughts onL.L. Bean Class Action Says Customers Cheated by New Return Policy
Add me
add me.
Add me.
My grandchildren purchased bookbags from L.L.Bean at the beginning of the schoolyear 2017. It was referred to them from all of their friends because of the high quality of their products and the forever warranty. I realize that kids are hard on bookbags, especially in the upper grades, that is why they returned their generic bag for L.L.Bean product and paid 3 times as much. It is well worth it if they hold to their promise of the warranty.
Add me
Add me please, LLBean is the main shopping, I do for my family. Because of their warranties.
Add me please!
Please add me to this suit. All three family members bought shoes from LLBean, last summer, Boots, Sandals, and New Balance sport shoes. Part of the reason we spend money here is BECAUSE of the (old) return policy.
I understand that they rewrote the police because some folks were kinda taking it a bit far… wearing a pair of their excellent boots for five YEARS… til they started to wear out and THEN turning them in for new ones…
For the prices they charge, I don’t think expecting stuff to last for two or three years is off the mark. I have one LLBean shirt that is 20 years old and STILL looks great… and a dress that is 18years old, still in perfect shape… and yupper, I’ve worn both… A LOT. LOL
Add us to the law suit as well
Add me please,