According to the HTC EVO class action lawsuit, the AccuWeather app is supposed “to make weather information conveniently available” by determining where the EVO user is, but HTC America is using the “unnecessarily precise” data to “display behaviorally targeted advertising to those users.”
“Defendants have used and continue to use the application to track plaintiffs’ exact geographic location for Defendants’ own purposes unrelated to weather information,” states the EVO AccuWeather class action lawsuit. This includes profiting off users by analyzing their behavior, building profiles of them, and sharing the profile information with third parties.
The Plaintiffs say AccuWeather tracks users’ location to within a few feet of where they are holding their smartphones, when it only needs to be accurate within a few blocks. They also object to the fact that unencrypted data about their location is transmitted over the Internet.
“This is a substandard practice for transmitting individuals’ precise location data and is unnecessary, since HTC smartphones are capable of transmitting data over the Internet using SSL encryption,” the EVO location tracking class action lawsuit states.
“In addition, the AccuWeather [app] has the capability to read the smartphone’s unique device identifier, send text messages, modify events on the calendar, and transmit email messages.”
Plaintiffs say the EVO also has another “unreasonable security defect” called “HTCLoggers,” which lets third-party apps access all the data on the user’s phone, including their email addresses, phone numbers for calls dialed and received, fine and course location and location history, text messages, and activity logs for all apps running on the smartphone.
“Essentially, all information regarding all activity on the smartphone.”
“HTC Corporation reportedly has acknowledged the HTCLogger defect but has failed to alert purchasers, rectify the defect, investigate AccuWeather’s use and/or onward transfer of purchasers’ detailed geographic location data, or remediate AccuWeather’s retention of such data,” states the EVO AccuWeather class action lawsuit.
The plaintiffs say they would not have paid a premium price for the phones if they knew about these security “defects.”
The EVO class action lawsuit is brought on behalf of all U.S. residents who purchased the HTC EVO 3D and/or the HTC EVO 4G smartphone. It is seeking refunds for Class Members, a replacement smartphone or the premium they paid for the phones, and a court order to fix the defects in the phones and purge all personal location data HTC collected.
A copy of the HTC EVO AccuWeather Class Action Lawsuit can be read here.
The case is Chad Goodman, et al. v. HTC America, Inc and AccuWeather.com, Inc., Case No. 11-cv-01793, U.S. District Court, Western District of Washington at Seattle.