
eBay Sued for Discriminating Against Deaf People
By Sarah Pierce
A deaf woman named Melissa J. Earll sued eBay this week for violating the Americans with Disabilities Act. In the lawsuit, Earll claims she tried multiple times to register as a seller but was unable to because the company requires prospective merchants to verify their identities over the telephone. Earll spent two months corresponding with eBay in an attempt to let her use an alternative verification system, but was unsuccessful. The suit says she was prevented from using eBay’s services “solely because of her disability.”
Earll is seeking monetary damages and an injunction requiring eBay to change its discriminatory phone policy so that deaf people can register as sellers. She proposes the company accomplish this by using CAPTCHAs (Completely Automated Public Turning test to tell Computers and Humans Apart) to verify new merchants. CAPTCHAs is used by thousands of online companies to assist deaf customers.
“What makes eBay’s discriminatory conduct all the more galling is that solutions to this problem are easy and inexpensive to implement — solutions being used by thousands of companies online,” the Earll says in the lawsuit.
Earll is seeking class-action status on behalf of all deaf or hard of hearing persons who have been unable to register with eBay because of its discriminatory telephone registration system.
{loadposition content_emailadd}
Updated March 19th, 2010
All class action and lawsuit news updates are listed in the Lawsuit News section of Top Class Actions
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
{loadposition content_ghome}


3 thoughts oneBay Sued for Discriminating Against Deaf People
See above.
I am deaf and do not even have a phone. I use email to do everything. Tonight I bid on an item at full price by a seller and in big red letters, I who have been a member for 14 years and made over 1100 transactions was told that the seller would not accept me as a customer even though she wouldn’t use paypal and required cleared checks for payment!
I am on the verge of tears. The FCC in 2010 made it pretty clear that the deaf were to have equal access to everything and we just are not getting it. Ebay’s treats all of it’s customers shabbily and this has to stop because no retail store in the land would be permitted to play the games they are playing and adding to all of the time.
I will keep the transaction number and the related information but will of course not be “permitted to buy something.”
I do not understand.. I am deaf and eBay power seller I have berm a member since 1993 Never have a problem with eBay
Do you have a phone ?
Do you have VRS ?
Are you early or late deaf ?
That is strange !