Simply Orange PFAS class action lawsuit overview:ย
- Who: A New York man has filed a revised class action lawsuit against Coca-Cola and its subsidiary Simply Orange Juice Co.ย
- Why: The plaintiff says the company sells juices that contain PFAS, otherwise known as forever chemicals.ย
- Where: The Simply Orange PFAS class action lawsuit was filed in a New York federal court.ย
A month after a manโs class action lawsuit against Coca-Cola and its subsidiary, Simply Orange Juice Co., was dismissed, heโs filed a revised version โ this time alleging heโs tested multiple juices made by the brands and found harmful chemicals in all of them.ย
New York resident Joseph Lurenz filed the amended complaint on July 9 in a New York federal court, alleging violations of state and federal consumer laws.ย
Lurenz claims that Simply juices contain significant levels of per- and polyfluoroalkyl (PFAS) compounds, based on independent testing.ย
PFAS are also known as โforever chemicalsโ because they are resistant to breaking down. They are artificially produced chemicals used to enhance everyday products like stain resistant clothing and furniture, cosmetics, and food packaging material.
However, PFAS can also have an impact on human health that scientists are just starting to understand, Lurenz says.ย
โScientists are studyingโand are extremely concerned aboutโhow PFAS affect human health,โ he says. โConsequently, the (Centers for Disease Control) outlined โa host of health effects associated with PFAS exposure, including cancer, liver damage, decreased fertility, and increased risk of asthma and thyroid disease.โโย
Plaintiff files amended complaint, with new research
Lurenz claims that the juices are deceptively marketed as pure, healthy and all natural, due to the presence of PFAS.
His original complaint was dismissed by Judge Nelson Roman last month, who said Lurenzโs claims were based on test results that were not adequately connected to his own purchases of Simply Orange products. The judge ruled that the plaintiffโs claim relied on only a single allegation of testing that found PFAS in the juice and โcites no studies or articles indicating that the product generally contains PFAS.โย
Since then, Lurenz says he has obtained independent third-party testing that found โwidespread and uniform contaminationโ of Simply Orange products, with levels of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) in Simply Tropical more than 100 times higher than lifetime health advisory levels the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency deemed safe for drinking water.ย
He says he tested a range of Simply Orange products that he bought, including pulp-free versions of Simply Orange and Simply Orange with Mango. He says the products contained significant levels of PFAS.ย
โThus, there is no possibility that the PFAS contamination is limited to a single unit or a single product line โ it is now more than plausible that the entirety of defendantsโ product line is contaminated and that this issue is systemic,โ he alleges.ย
Simply Orange PFAS false advertising claims
Despite this, the company continues to market Simply Orange as โnaturalโ and give the impression it is safe and healthy through the use of terms like โpure filtered waterโ and โall-natural ingredients,โ he says.ย
He is looking to represent anyone who bought a Simply juice in the United States.ย
He is suing for violations of the New York Deceptive Trade Practices Act and New York State Agriculture and Markets Law, as well as negligence and unjust enrichment, and is seeking certification of the class action, damages, fees, costs and a jury trial.ย
What do you think of the claims in this Simply class action lawsuit? Let us know in the comments.ย
The plaintiff is represented by Jason P. Sultzer and Philip J. Furia of Sultzer & Lipari PLLC and Nick Suciu III, Gary Klinger, Erin Ruben and J. Hunter Bryson of Milberg Coleman Bryson Phillips Grossman PLLC.ย
The Simply Orange PFAS class action is Joseph Lurenz v. The Coca-Cola Co., Case No. 7:22-cv-10941, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
Donโt Miss Out!
Check out our list of Class Action Lawsuits and Class Action Settlements you may qualify to join!
Read About More Class Action Lawsuits & Class Action Settlements:
893 thoughts onRevised class action says all Simply Orange juice products contain PFAS
We buy these and the Simply Lemonade. Please add me
I have had a lot of health issues and drank extra OJ in the last 2.5 years.
please add me.
Of course, I wouldnโt doubt it. Americaโs fda, usda, cdc, etc is terrible. They keep us sick. Food dyes causes cancers per medical journals and studies in the uk. Enriched (bleached) flour etc. Bleach sounds healthy. We must all look into the ingredients list and see if itโs healthy or not. Slop is going to be cheap. Clean fresh foods are going to be a little bit more expensive. But since inflation happened itโs literally like $0.50-$1.00 difference. Plus itโs not full of fillers. Like Walmart hamburger has it packed with dyes and fillers. $5/lb for grass fed 80/20 at anther store (fresh thyme), or fills you up faster the less you eat. Please eat healthy itโll help so much
We use two of these juices.
Please add me
I buy 5 of these jugs each week for myself and my family/kids. Please add me. I will not buy ever again.
I buy 5 of these jugs each week for myself and my family/kids. Please add me.
I have always bought simple products thinking I was buying the best. After reading the article I will not. I will research to find other brands for my family. Please add me.
Please add me. I have bought their products for a very long timeโฆ.
Yikes, I purchase Simple products all the time. I will not purchase another Simple anything.
Please add me to the list.
I have bought many a Simple orange juice thinking that it is very healthy would not buy another one. Will like to join the class action suit.