Benjamin Moore Natura Paint Class Action Lawsuit
By Matt O’Donnell
Paint company Benjamin Moore peddles its Natura brand interior paint as “virtually odorless” and “quick-drying,” but a federal class action lawsuit says the paint remains stinky and sticky for months, rendering the rooms in which it is used virtually uninhabitable. What’s more, the class action says, when consumers complained about the paint, Moore issued a deficient “Product Replacement” notice to retailers that did not admit the extent of the problem.
According to the class action lawsuit, Benjamin Moore Natura paint is marketed as “a great choice for those concerned about indoor air quality” because it is “virtually odorless” and “dries to the touch in 30 minutes.” However, not only does it emit a strong, foul, persistent odor, it also fails to dry in 30 minutes as promised and remains wet and sticky for months, says the class action lawsuit.
The Benjamin Moore Natura paint class action lawsuit claims that had consumers known the paint didn’t deliver on its advertised promises, they would not have purchased the more expensive Natura paint. In fact, even if Benjamin Moore didn’t misrepresent that Natura is odorless and dries quickly, “no reasonable consumer would purchase the product if he or she knew that it emits an offensive, acute and enduring odor and that the product does not dry completely even months after it is applied,” the class action states.
The class action goes on to say that after a slew of consumer complaints, Moore knew that its Natura paint did not perform as advertised, yet did not inform its retail outlets of that fact. Instead, it issued a “Product Replacement” notice that was crafted to omit any reference to any problem with the paint and left it up to the retailers to decide if they wanted to replace their stock with new versions of the product. Furthermore, Moore never instructed its retailers to make any effort to contact customers who had already purchased the paint and inform them of the problem or to remedy the harm those customers were suffering as a result of the problem.
The Natura paint class action lawsuit is brought on behalf of all persons in the United States who purchased Natura paint during the applicable statute of limitations. It is asking that the Moore be required to conduct a corrective advertising campaign and implement “whatever measures are necessary to remedy the unlawful, unfair and fraudulent business acts or practices, untrue and misleading advertising and other violations of law.”
A copy of the Benjamin Moore Natura Paint Class Action Lawsuit can be read here.
Updated April 30th, 2011
All class action and lawsuit news updates are listed in the Lawsuit News section of Top Class Actions
Top Class Actions Legal Statement


One thought on Benjamin Moore Natura Paint Class Action Lawsuit
Benjamin Moore Natura Paint Class Action Lawsuit
I’ve used Benjamin Moore Natura throughout my entire house. While I’ve noticed a faint odor while painting, it’s nothing compared to a regular paint. It dried like they said it would and haven’t smelled a thing since. I’ve never experienced any of the problems outlined in this suit and I’ve used 8 gallons in 6 different colors. Maybe they had a bad batch but I don’t think their advertising is misleading based on my experience with this product.