A federal judge has rejected two marketing companies’ argument that a federal law banning text message spam is unconstitutional. The decision clears the way for Illinois resident Christopher Kramer to move forward with a potential class action lawsuit against the companies for allegedly sending him unsolicited text advertisements.
Kramer sued mobile ad company B2Mobile, lead-generation company LeadClick, and car-buying website Autobytel last year for sending unsolicited text ads to his cell phone, citing the federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act, which has been interpreted to require companies to obtain users’ “prior express consent.” Kramer alleges in the potential text ad class action that B2Mobile, LeadClick and Autobytel sent him 10 text messages without his permission, including nine texts that arrived after he expressly opted out of receiving the text ads.
Kramer’s claims against Autobytel were ultimately dismissed in October 2010, and B2Mobile and LeadClick attempted to have the class action lawsuit against them also dismissed on the grounds that the TCPA is too vague because it doesn’t specify the types of actions that constitute “prior consent.”
U.S. District Court Judge Claudia Wilken rejected their argument, however, ruling that the TCPA is not too vague to be enforced. Wilken said previous court decisions and rulings by the Federal Communications Commission provided “ample guidance” about how to determine whether users had given marketers permission to send text ads.
Other marketers who were sued for sending text message spam have unsuccessfully argued in the past that the Telephone Consumer Protection Act doesn’t apply to wireless ads, saying the law prohibits companies from using automatic telephone dialing systems to make calls to cell phones unless the owners have consented. But courts have recently held that the law also applies to SMS ads.
The most recent cases include a class action lawsuit settlement over text ads for the release of the Robots DVD, a Burger King text ad class action settlement, and class action lawsuit settlement over text ads for Stephen King’s book “Cell.” All settlements garnered a hefty award for class members.
Updated January 4th, 2010
All class action and lawsuit news updates are listed in the Lawsuit News section of Top Class Actions
Top Class Actions Legal Statement

