Have Unum’s Fraudulent Ways Really Changed?
By Andrea Gressman
In 2008, a federal jury in Boston found Unum guilty of fraud. Unum is the nation’s largest disability insurance provider and the target of numerous lawsuits alleging the company repeatedly denies paying legitimate disability claims. Unum was found guilty of fraud because it required some customers to apply for Social Security benefits to receive disability, even though Unum knew the customers were ineligible. Although a couple of years have passed since this guilty verdict was handed down people are wondering if Unum learned anything for this experience or if they have just attempted to develop different tactics to get away with the same behavior. This is at the front of many policyholders’ minds because of the many shady tactics that are still being reported today.
Details of the Unum Fraud Lawsuit
The Unum fraud lawsuit was filed on behalf of the Social Security Administration under the federal whistleblower statute, which allows private citizens to file a lawsuit on the behalf of a government program in the instance where fraud is being committed. This Unum fraud lawsuit was heard in the U.S. District Court in Boston. Despite Unum being found guilty, both sides declared victory. The court presented the jury with six Unum lawsuits to resolve. The jury resolved five of the six claims (the jury apparently hung on Unum lawsuit number six). Of the five resolved Unum lawsuits, the jury found two claims were fraudulent. However, the jury also found that three claims were not fraudulent. Thus, lawyers declared this to be a so-called split-verdict.
In 2007 Unum paid $4 billion in benefits across 400,000 disability claims. Given the huge numbers, the parties agreed to try six claims, instead of 400,000 claims to the jury. The next phase of Unum lawsuit litigation will be to determine — from the jury’s decision on the six claims presented — whether and to what extent Unum’s practices harmed the Social Security program.
Unum Still Declares Victory Despite Guilty Verdict
A Unum spokesperson, Jim Sabourin, declared that since only two of the six claims involved fraud that this was not only a victory for Unum, but also showed the Unum lawsuit was without merit. He declared, “[t]he jury rejected the claim that there was any systemic problem with the way Unum adjudicates its claims.” Moreover, Mr. Sabourin declared that Unum would appeal the portion of the verdict that was adverse to Unum.
On the other hand, the plaintiff’s attorney spoke for her client, Patrick Loughren. She said she was delighted that the jury found it was fraudulent to require able-bodied people to seek Social Security. Moreover, the Unum lawsuit attorney stated, “I think that Unum is going to have to change its practices” and they will need to “screen people” before insisting they apply for Social Security disability benefits. However, it is still unclear to this day whether or not Unum has done so – especially since they are evidently waving the victory flag despite the guilty verdict in two Unum fraud lawsuits.
In the meanwhile, Mark Hinkle, a representative of the Social Security Administration, said while the agency was monitoring the Unum lawsuit, they were not in a position to comment upon the legislation.
Filing a Unum Fraud Lawsuit
If you have been the victim of a Unum policy denial for a legitimate claim or Unum has encouraged you to participate in a fraudulent activity it is imperative that you contact a Unum lawsuit attorney right away. Visit the Unum/UnumProvident Disability Insurance Claim Denial Class Action Lawsuit Investigation page to learn more about your legal options. Receive your free consultation from a qualified Unum lawsuit lawyer. It is also important to note that in a whistleblowers lawsuit that the private citizen is also eligible to receive a portion of the compensation recovered in the whistleblower lawsuit and there are currently attorneys standing by that can help you file a whistleblower lawsuit as well.
Updated December 14th, 2012
{loadposition content_postads}
All employment related class action and lawsuit news updates are listed in the Employment and Labor section of Top Class Actions
Top Class Actions Legal Statement

