UPDATE: On Nov. 6, 2020, a proposed class action lawsuit against Walmart over its temporary pandemic return policy was allowed to inch forward after a judge ruled employees of the retail giant inconsistently applied rules about whether consumers can return goods.
A California woman has filed a class action lawsuit against Walmart, accusing the retail giant of changing its return policy during the coronavirus crisis.
Plaintiff Danielle Hubmer says the company altered its normal return policy without posting any signage or otherwise letting customers know about the changes.
Hubmer claims she purchased items, including clothing, at a California Walmart store on April 25.
According to the Walmart class action lawsuit, the dressing room at the store was closed when she was shopping, so she was not able to try on any of the clothing items she planned to purchase.
She also says she did not see any signage or item tags that displayed a new COVID-19 return policy.
Despite not being able to try the clothing on, Hubmer made her purchases and left the store.
On April 27, Hubmer says she returned to the store to attempt to return some of the items she had purchased two days earlier.
The Walmart class action lawsuit says she was compliant with Walmart’s normal return policy in that she was within the window of time during which the store allows returns and the items still had the tags on.
However, the Walmart lawsuit claims, Walmart refused to take back Hubmer’s items and “refused to provide Plaintiff with a cash refund, store credit, or an equal exchange for the full price of the purchase of her goods.”
Instead, the store manager told Hubmer the store was not accepting returns.
The Walmart class action lawsuit claims Walmart employees are not typically trained in the company’s return policies and in many instances are giving consumers “a wide array” of misinformation regarding the policies.
The lack of correct information given to consumers by Walmart employees is “widespread and pervasive,” the Walmart lawsuit claims, and even web searches for the company’s return policy yields thousands of customer complaints.
As of June 17, an article on Walmart’s help page says: “As part of our COVID-19 response, we will temporarily not allow store returns on certain items. For the most up-to-date information, please visit Walmart’s Policies and Guidelines website.”
The Polices and Guidelines website’s most up-to-date information, dated June 15, says the retailer “paused processing returns and exchanges” for several categories of items, including clothing for “a number of weeks.” However, no information was available on when the alleged “pause” began.
According to the site, as of June 15, the retailer is once again accepting returns “in most states” in accordance with its normal policy, and “any items that were temporarily not permitted for return and were purchased between April 20 and June 15 can now be returned through Sept. 15 with a receipt.”
The Walmart class action lawsuit alleges the company is in violation of the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, the California Business and Professions Code and California civil code. The complaint also accuses Walmart of breach of contract.
Hubmer claims she and other potential Class Members entered into a contract with the retailer at the time the purchases were made, and Walmart broke that contract when they refused to allow the return of the items.
Hubmer is seeking compensatory damages due to Walmart’s alleged breach of contract; damages as a result of the company’s “unlawful, unfair, fraudulent and deceptive practices;” injunctive relief to stop such practices; punitive damages; court costs; attorneys’ costs and fees; interest; and any other relief the Court deems proper.
She is also demanding a jury trial.
The number of potential Class Members is unknown, but according to the Walmart class action lawsuit, the number could be in the hundreds of thousands.
Hubmer says a class action lawsuit is proper in this case because given the size of claims of individual Class Members, “few, if any, could afford to seek legal redress” individually. Once the defendant’s liability is established, the class action lawsuit will “permit an orderly and expeditious administration” of Class Members’ claims.
The plaintiff claims that without a class action lawsuit, “Class Members will continue to suffer damages, Defendant’s violations of law will proceed without remedy, and Defendant will continue to reap and retain the substantial proceeds of its wrongful conduct.”
Find out more about your legal rights regarding COVID-19 with Top Class Actions’ complete coronavirus guide.
Have you tried to return items to a retailer during COVID-19? Have they refused to take back your items? Tell us your story in the comments section below.
Hubmer is represented by Mitch Kalcheim of Kalcheim Law Group PC.
The Walmart COVID-19 Return Policy Class Action Lawsuit is Danielle Hubmer, et al. v. Walmart Inc., Case No. RIC2001569, in the Superior Court of California for the County of Riverside.
Join a Free Coronavirus Class Action Lawsuit Investigation
If you believe your rights were violated in a way that is directly related to the coronavirus pandemic, you may qualify to join this coronavirus class action lawsuit investigation.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2024 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.
857 thoughts onWalmart Class Action Lawsuit: COVID-19 Return Policy Unfair
Ms. Hubmer’s Walmart return experience is the same as mine. I’ve gone back to the store twice and still cannot get even an estimated date when returns will be accepted.
I even started the return process online at Walmart.com and was instructed to take the email back to the store for my refund. There was no mention of the new COVID return policy that I noticed there either.
add me please
I want to relate a quick briefing on behalf of my grandmother Dianne. She SUFFERS around the clock with various aialments and make her daily tasks extremely difficult to perform. She is diagnosed with congestive heart failure, Chrones disease and diabetes to mention a few. My grandmother fights these pains all day. Then had to adjust to a new opponent when Covid-19 hit El Cajon and everything became a struggle. She over came and kept optimistic that we the collective people would surely band together and work in harmony to protect our community. Then something simple to Walmart like refusing to refund the petinse she managed to finally save for a new set of Womens undergarments, became a HUGE problem for my grandmother. A problem that shows the apathy and malfeasance of Walmarts policy makers towards us the consumers. And I plain won’t stand for it. Walmart and all individuals assisted with this disregard for my Grandmothers well being should absolutely be ashamed of themselves. I want to use profanity and inappropriate remarks to convey my displeasure but will not because I understand that I have a responsibility to my fellow man in keeping our community not only physically healthy but mentally healthy as well. So please, regardless of the outcome, strive to do the right thing here. Walmart, will you compromise your integrity and policy, in effect, taking up fighting in unison with Covid-19?
Same here. Kids needed summer clothes. They’ve grown and I guessed sizes wrong. Changing rooms closed. No signs saying returns wouldn’t be allowed but I’m now stuck with several hundred dollars of clothes that aren’t the right size for my kids and no way to return them. Walmart’s site says most states are now allowing returns but not Indiana… We shopped at Meijers’, who is allowing returns, after we realized, but I still have this huge return pile and money tied up in items I need to return…
add me.
A couple of weeks ago I purchased 2 pair of running shorts that I could not try on in the store. When I brought them home I tried one pair on and decided I didn’t like the fit. When I went to Walmart to return them the employee pointed to a sign saying “temporary restrictions on returns” that was taped to the spit shield in front of her register. She said they couldn’t take back CLOTHING “because of the virus”. There was nothing posted in the clothing areas on the floor. I had no idea I wouldn’t be able to return something if I purchased it. They would not give me a refund or store credit but she said I could return it when the ban is lifted. How will I know when that is and until then you’re tying up my money??
Add me because they should have a written policy in clear view so you can decide if you want to purchase or not.
I purchased a few things before the outbreak. I realized I grabbed the wrong thing after. At this point the outbreak is full effect. I knew nothing about the change in return policy and I bought these things before. I just wanted the correct items not even a return and the wouldn’t do that. Like it was food something I definitely needed in this time. I still have the items. Such a inconvenience. Like I didn’t care if you didn’t put it back on the shelf I just wanted an exchange. I felt like it could of been handled differently. Not a happy consumer and I watch what I buy now or not even go because of that reason. Feel like I was robbed!
Add me please and thanks. We work hard for that money we spend! We also spent a lot of time in those long return lines to be turned away!
Same thing for me..wouldn’t take back.. Wouldn’t exchange..no signage posted…dressing rooms closed…please add me..this was the Wal Mart in Elkhart Indiana.
Please add me.
Please add me I’ve tried several times trying to make a return and they are not taking returns.