On Friday, a California state appeals court denied Uber’s attempts to arbitrate claims that the company tricks Lyft drivers by requiring its own drivers to create fake Lyft accounts to hurt the competing company.
This decision confirms a previous decision made by a lower court.
Plaintiff Ryan Smythe, a driver for both Lyft and Uber, alleges that Uber requires its drivers to create fake Lyft accounts in order to send Lyft drivers to pick up fake customers, in an attempt to discourage drivers from driving for Lyft and thereby hurt their business.
The state appeals court confirmed the decision by a California Superior Court judge that allegations made in the recent Uber class action lawsuit are beyond the scope of an arbitration agreement that Smythe signed with Uber when he agreed to drive for them.
The state appeals court rejected Uber’s attempt to have the lawsuit thrown out based on an agreement that Smythe signed when he started employment with Uber that stated that he would handle legal disputes relating to his employment with Uber in arbitration.
According to the court order, “the same allegations could just as well be pursued by a Lyft driver who does not drive for Uber…Uber’s attempt to cast this as a dispute about Smythe’s ‘dual identity’ as a driver with both Lyft and Uber thus misses the mark.”
In Smythe’s Uber Lyft fake passenger class action lawsuit, he claims that Uber tried to hurt Lyft’s business by using its drivers to set up fake Lyft accounts and order rides with no intention of riding in the Lyft, thereby sending Lyft drivers on “wild goose chases” after fake passengers. According to the Uber class action lawsuit, this was done to discourage drivers from driving for Lyft, and hurting the business’ profits.
Uber attempted to claim that this practice was part of its marketing, to no avail. The appeals court stated that Uber’s attempt to “[send] its primary competitor’s drivers on wild goose chases to pick up nonexistent passengers, whether or not with the aim of increasing its own ridership, cannot plausibly be called ‘advertising’ or ‘marketing.’”
Smythe says this practice is widespread at Uber, and he seeks to represent a Class of Lyft drivers who he claims lost wages because of Uber’s allegedly unfair business practice.
Fighting back at this claim, Uber argues that the practice was designed to entice Lyft drivers to drive for Uber instead of Lyft. User’s representation also argued that Smythe was required to participate in this practice as part of his terms of employment with Uber, because allegedly, the agreement he signed with Uber mentioned Uber’s right to entice new users to the service.
Judge Mary E. Wiss disagreed, as part of her decision to deny Uber’s arbitration bid. Uber then argued that Judge Wiss had erred in her decision, and sought an appeal with the state appeals court.
But, the state appeals court agreed that Smythe’s Uber arbitration agreement didn’t fall within the scope of his employment with Uber, especially as he eliminated claims related to wage and working hours, which were initially included in the complaint because of a drafting error.
Smythe is represented by Jeffrey Fulton of the Law Office of Jeffrey D. Fulton, and R. Parker White and William Brelsford of Poswall White & Brelsford.
The Uber Lyft Fake Account Class Action Lawsuit is Ryan Smythe v. Uber Technologies, et al., Case No. A149891, in the California Court of Appeals for the First Appellate District, Division Three.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2026 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.

