California employers should pay close attention to a February 2019 decision by a state court of appeals requiring retail workers to be paid for being on call.
The decision stems from a class-action lawsuit brought by retail workers scheduled to work regular shifts, but also assigned on-call shifts, the latter requiring workers to call in two hours before their shifts were scheduled to begin to find out if they were needed. If they were told not to come in, the workers did not receive any pay, according to the Society for Human Resource Management.
The National Law Review calls the decision “precedent-setting,” because it establishes that California employees may be paid for being on-call, even if they ever get called in to work.
The panel of judges in this case was divided in its decision.
The discussion centered on whether requiring a worker to be on call, and then requiring them to call in to work to see if they were needed, constitutes the worker having reported.
If this act was considered reporting, it would fall under California’s Industrial Welfare Commission wage orders, which requires employers to pay workers “reporting time pay” for each work day in which “an employee is required to report for work and does report, but is not put to work or is furnished less than half said employee’s usual or scheduled day’s work.”
Based on the February decision, calling in to work for an on-call shift constitute reporting pay, and the worker is entitled to be paid for being on call in California.
“On-call shifts burden employees, who cannot take other jobs, go to school, or make social plans during on call shifts — but who nonetheless receive no compensation from [the employer] unless they are ultimately called in to work,” according to the appeals court’s decision.
They went on to say that “report for work” did indeed mean physically report for work, as the law was created before current technologies, but decided that it would enact a new interpretation of California’s Industrial Wage Commission, the agency responsible for setting overtime wages, hours and working conditions for workers.
The judges wrote that “reporting for work” translates to both reporting physically for work, or “presenting [onesself] in whatever manner the employer has directed” — on the phone, for instance.
In the dissenting judges opinion, the court should stay true to the more traditional interpretation of the law, maintaining that workers should not be paid for being on call. In her dissenting opinion, Justice Anne H. Egerton wrote that the court’s “fundamental task in interpreting Wage Orders is ascertaining the drafters’ intent, not drawing up interpretations that promote the Court’s view of good policy.”
Justice Egerton went on to argue that “call-in shifts do not trigger reporting-time penalties, even if the scheduling practice is inconvenient and employee-unfriendly.”
The issue of getting paid for being on call paying is hotly debated. Many employees required to be on call without compensation — a substantial number of whom are low-paid, hourly workers, often in the food industry — call the practice unfair.
The federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) “establishes minimum wage, overtime pay, recordkeeping, and child labor standards affecting full-time and part-time workers in the private sector and in Federal, State, and local governments.”
The FLSA also outlines the guidelines for when workers are paid for on-call hours.
Some states are fighting back against the practice of not paying workers for being on call. Now in California, workers required to be available for call-in shifts, but are not called into work, should be compensated for two hours of reporting time.
And as of July 1, 2018, in Oregon, employers are required by law to provide workers with written work schedules at least seven calendar days before the first day of work. In certain cases, if an employer changes a written work schedule, without notifying the worked within at least seven calendar days before the work week is to begin, the employer must give the employee an additional hour of pay in addition to regular pay earned.
In 2016, nine attorneys general investigated the practice, resulting in some retailers revisiting their approach to the practice, according to Forbes.
Join a Free On-Call Shift Lawsuit Investigation
If you work or are scheduled for on-call shifts in retail or fast food in Oregon or California, you may qualify for this on-call worker class action lawsuit investigation.
This article is not legal advice. It is presented
for informational purposes only.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2026 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.

