Citgo Retirement Benefits Class Action Lawsuit Overview:
- Who: Citgo is asking a judge for the second time to dismiss a class action lawsuit filed against it by a pair of the company’s retirees, Mark Pelligrini and Leslie Urlaub.
- Why: Citgo argues Pelligrini and Urlaub did not show they had been harmed or make a valid claim that they had been shortchanged by the company on their retirement benefits.
- Where: The class action lawsuit was filed in Illinois federal court.
Citgo Petroleum Corp. is once again asking a federal judge in Illinois to dismiss a class action lawsuit lobbied at it by former employees claiming the company shorted them on their retirement benefits.
Citgo had previously filed a motion to dismiss in October and is now responding to a November opposition from plaintiffs Mark Pelligrini and Leslie Urlaub.
Pelligrini and Urlaub claim in their class action lawsuit that Citgo used actuarial assumptions that were outdated by 50 years when calculating their retirement benefit packages.
“For employees who commenced benefits after Jan. 1, 2018, defendants use a mortality table that is updated every single year yet they continue to apply the same outdated 1971 mortality table to harm the older workers,” Pelligrini and Urlaub said in their opposition to dismiss, Law360 reports.
Citgo, however, claims the retirees did not adequately show they had been harmed or make a valid claim under the Employee Retirement Security Act.
“For all of Plaintiffs’ attempts to find a hook to hang a claim, neither Plaintiff alleges facts to show that their subsidized early retirement benefits violate these provisions—which, in turn, dooms their fiduciary claim,” Citgo says in its motion to dismiss.
Citgo Argues Retirees Chose To Receive Early Retirement Benefits Actually Calculated At Higher Rate
Citgo argues the retirees chose to receive early retirement benefits, which the company claims were actually calculated at a higher rate than if they had simply chosen to receive them at their normal retirement age.
“Crucially, Plaintiffs fail to plead any facts to suggest that the value of their JSA at retirement—increased by their preferred actuarial factors—would exceed the value of the subsidized early retirement pensions they actually are receiving,” the company says.
Citgo agreed to pay $19 million last year to settle a separate class action lawsuit alleging its tractor fluid was not up to modern day specifications and could damage equipment.
Are you a Citgo retiree who believes you were owed more in your retirement benefits? Let us know in the comments!
The plaintiffs are represented by Peter K. Stris, Rachana A. Pathak, Victor O’Connell and John Stokes of Stris & Maher LLP; Michelle C. Yau, Daniel J. Sutter and Carol V. Gilden of Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC; Todd Jackson and Nina Wasow of Feinberg Jackson Worthman & Wasow LLP; and Shaun P. Martin of the University of San Diego School of Law.
The Citgo Retirement Benefits Class Action Lawsuit is Urlaub, et al. v. Citgo Petroleum Corp., et al., Case No. 1:21-cv-04133, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.
Don’t Miss Out!
Check out our list of Class Action Lawsuits and Class Action Settlements you may qualify to join!
Read About More Class Action Lawsuits & Class Action Settlements:
- Judge Approves Negligence Claims in Delta Jet Fuel Dump Class Action
- United Airlines Argues Texas Plaintiffs Upset Over Vaccine Mandate Cannot Represent Nationwide Class
- Delta Airlines Baggage Handler Co Can’t Get BIPA Class Action Tossed
- Boeing, Southwest Ask Judge to Halt 737 RICO Class Action Lawsuit


One thought on Citgo Asks Again For Dismissal Of Claims It Shortchanged Retirees On Their Benefits
Worked for Citgo in the 60s..for about 11 years.they gave me back my base pension investment at a 2% interest rate