A recent dismissal has opened up the possibility for a group of Carnival cruise customers to appeal an arbitration order in their travel insurance class action lawsuit.
Although a federal judge dismissing a class action lawsuit usually spells disaster for plaintiffs and the proposed Class, U.S. District Judge Kathleen M. Williams’ recent decision was a favorable outcome for the plaintiffs.
In her dismissal order, Judge Williams noted that she and the plaintiffs agreed that the case would need to be dismissed to stop the stay on the case so that they could appeal an arbitration decision in appellate court.
“Further, [consumers] claim that lifting the stay is in the public interest because it will allow the Eleventh Circuit to clarify the proper test for determining whether a claim falls within the scope of a broad arbitration provision, which is unsettled in this circuit. The court agrees,” Judge Williams wrote.
In late January, the consumers urged Judge Williams to lift the stay on the case so that they could appeal the arbitration order.
They argued that a 2014 decision by the Eleventh Circuit in Martinez v. Carnival Corp. determined that the circuit court doesn’t have jurisdiction over an arbitration order unless that order is final. However, the order could not be final if the case remained stayed.
“Based on Martinez, the fact that the court stayed the case may prevent the Eleventh Circuit from reviewing the arbitration order as a final order and thus may cause the Eleventh Circuit to require additional briefing on the jurisdiction issue, which will only delay this case,” the consumers argued in their January motion.
Carnival, a popular cruise company, rejected this argument after it was made by the consumers. The company argued that if the court lifted the stay and dismissed the case, they would be undermining the Federal Arbitration Act.
However, Judge Williams ended up siding with the plaintiffs in this decision. She notes that the Eleventh Circuit now has the potential to make a groundbreaking determination of arbitration agreements and resolve issues that are unsettled in the circuit.
“Plaintiffs claim that lifting the stay is in the public interest because it will allow the Eleventh Circuit to clarify the proper test for determining whether a claim falls within the scope of a broad arbitration provision, which is unsettled in this Circuit,” Judge Williams wrote in her short four-page order.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs told Law 360 that they were “extremely glad” that Judge Williams sided with them on the motion so that the Eleventh Circuit Court could make a concrete ruling on the arbitration issue.
The consumers are represented by Adam M. Moskowitz, Howard M. Bushman, Adam A. Schwartzbaum and Joseph M. Kaye of The Moskowitz Law Firm PLLC, Andrew S. Friedman and Francis J. Balint Jr. of Bonnett Fairbourn Friedman & Balint PC, Kimberly Lambert Adams of Levin Papantonio Thomas Mitchell Rafferty Proctor PA and William F. “Chip” Merlin Jr. of the Merlin Law Group.
The Carnival Travel Insurance Class Action Lawsuit is Wolfe, et al. v. Carnival Corp., Case No. 1:18-cv-23463, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida.
UPDATE: The Carnival Travel Insurance Class Action Lawsuit was dismissed on May 15, 2019. Top Class Actions will let our viewers know if a new case is filed.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association
LEGAL INFORMATION IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Top Class Actions Legal Statement
©2008 – 2026 Top Class Actions® LLC
Various Trademarks held by their respective owners
This website is not intended for viewing or usage by European Union citizens.

